← Posts

Advertising + Marketing

AI Doesn’t Replace Advertising Judgment

R Luquis · September 8, 2026 · 1 min

Illustration for “AI Doesn’t Replace Advertising Judgment”

At the agency, we use artificial intelligence every day: to explore concepts, write variations, analyze data, and automate repetitive processes. It’s changed our production speed in a way that would have seemed like science fiction five years ago.

But the claim that keeps coming up in the public conversation —that AI will replace strategists and creatives— is the one that holds up the least. What AI doesn’t have is judgment: the ability to know which idea will connect with a specific audience, at a specific moment, in a market as distinctive as Puerto Rico.

The best results we’ve seen from combining AI with human teams come from a clear division of labor: the machine delivers volume and speed; the human team decides what’s worthwhile, what’s relevant, and what strikes the right cultural chord. Without that second half, everything feels generic.

My advice to anyone in the industry isn’t to fear the tool, but to invest in what the tool can’t do: understand the client, read the market, edit with intention, and take responsibility for decisions. Good judgment has never commanded a higher price.

Share this piece

Got you thinking? Reach me on my socials or check out my work at Alterno Agency.

Comments

Comments are reviewed before they're published

No comments yet. Be the first.

Leave your comment

R Luquis

El autor

R Luquis

Sociologist and digital advertiser with more than 20 years of experience in digital media and brand development. Graduated in Sociology from the University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, with master's studies in Industrial/Organizational Psychology at the Inter American University of Puerto Rico.

I founded Alterno Agency in 2009, where we lead digital projects, advanced web development, and campaigns for leading Puerto Rican and international brands.

From Caguas, living in San Juan. Car enthusiast, cyclist, lover of music and food. Married to the love of my life and dad of three: two boys and a girl.

Alterno AgencyTransforma tu marca

My agency

Alterno Agency

Digital advertising and web development since 2009. Strategy, digital campaigns, web and content for brands of every size, from Puerto Rico outward.